Related
While it ’s always exciting for a belovedfantasybook to receive the big projection screen treatment , making change to major characters will always be a risky move . In some instances , character changes can facilitate bring up the story and actually feel like an betterment over what was depicted in the novel . However , making major change to the generator materialalso has the potential to enrage readers , ruin antecedently establish character arcs , or feel altogether unnecessary and in reality reduce the impact of the original story .
While many of thegreatest phantasy moviesof all time were based on preexisting books , inevitably some thing are break down to be changed as the fib is adapt for the blind . While all - time great film director likePeter Jackson did an sinful chore with his version ofThe Lord of the Rings , the reception to hisdivisive version ofThe Hobbitwere choice examples of how things can go untimely . It ’s intensely hard to keep everyone happy , and these were some examples of change that readers make out and others that they direct issue with .
BEST: Making Caspian A Teenager
The Chronicles of Narnia: Prince Caspian (2008)
C.S. Lewis’sChronicles of Narniawas among the most successful and dear fantasy book serial of all clock time , which meant the pic adjustment had a heap drive on them . While hearing woefully never got to see the integral series adapted , the film versions ofThe Lion , the Witch and the Wardrobe , Prince Caspian , andThe Voyage of the Dawn Treaderpowerfully brought the world of Narnia to life . While longtime readers were understandably suspicious of any change to the characters , the decision to age Prince Caspian up from a tiddler to a teenager was a wise one .
Your Rating
Your comment has not been saved
Cast
This character change not only made Caspian more relatable to adolescent audiences but also helped transmute the passiveness of the book ’s personation into a much more active character . Caspian ’s matureness and desire to reclaim the throne added higher stake to the story and imbued the film with a issue forth - of - age conflict that helped kick upstairs it . Add to this the addition of a romantic subplot between Caspian and Susan Pevensie , and it ’s remove the age change opened the doorway for more story possibilities .
WORST: Diluting Cardinal Stelmaria’s Ruthless Nature
The Golden Compass (2007)
The Golden Compasswas an adaptation of Philip Pullman ’s novelNorthern Lights , the first in theHis Dark Materialstrilogy . As a serial with a potent message about the rejection of religion and the misuse of power that pass within mental institution , the character of Cardinal Stelmaria was substantive in understanding the book ’s profound themes . However , as the novel was adapted , Cardinal Stelmaria ’s character was diluted beyond all acknowledgement , and the account fall back most of its thematic heft .
Rather than allowing Cardinal Stelmaria to present the ruthlessness of the Magisterium , he was instead a generic pocket-size opposer who neglect to effectively demonstrate the novel ’s oppressive undertones . While the Magisterium was still depicted as iniquity , Stelmaria ’s role as Lord Asriel ’s snow Panthera pardus dæmon felt like a water - down version of what was catch in the record , and this hurt the motion-picture show ’s shock . The later TV seriesHis Dark Materialsdid a far better job of bewitch the inwardness of the novel , makingThe Golden Compassfeel like an adaptation that is well leave about entirely .
BEST: Neville Longbottom
Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows - Part 2 (2011)
TheHarry Potterfilm series has been fairly criticize for glossing over many of the Word of God ’s subplots and failing to fully capture the dynamics , relationships , and chemistry between some of its character . However , one thing this fantasy dealership get veracious was Neville Longbottom , as , at times , his personation in the movies in reality provided his character with more agency and valiance than what was seen in the novels .
While Neville played an significant part in the Battle of Hogwarts in theDeathly Hallowsnovel , as he was the one who destroyed the snake Horcrux Nagini , in the picture , he delivered a powerful speech standing up to Voldemort . This heroic presentation was made all the more compelling consider how often Neville was the brunt of antic from scholarly person and instructor likewise in the early films . With a transformative performance from Matthew Lewis , the film version of Neville stand up out as a hero as intrepid and determined as Harry himself .
WORST: Merging Roland Deschain’s Story From Multiple Books Into One Film
The Dark Tower (2017)
While Stephen King has had many iconic novels that helped turn him into a fable of modern literature , it wasThe Dark Towerfantasy series that stood as his magnum opus . As sprawling nine Bible series , King incorporate dark phantasy , science fantasy , horror , and Western genres into an interconnected epic that brought together characters from his entire trunk of piece of work . While a film adaption was an ambitious endeavor , it had the potential to be truly great .
However , this potential was squander whenThe Dark Towerdecided to immix Roland Deschain ’s story from multiple books into the same film . alternatively of respecting the tempo and worldbuilding of the original series , The Dark Towerpacked as much of Roland ’s story as potential into its brief 95 - minute runtime . The results were a mess and a moving-picture show that most King fans like to pretend does not be at all .
BEST: Expanding Glinda’s Role
The Wizard of Oz (1939)
Glinda the Good Witch is as central to the story ofThe Wizard of Ozas Dorothy , Toto , and the Wicked Witch of the West , which take it all the more shocking to check sheonly appeared in the final chapter of L. Frank Baum ’s original novel . This reduced purpose limited the impact of the character reference in the book , and the movie made the correct conclusion when it evidence Glinda as the first person Dorothy encountered after landing in the enchanted world of Oz .
Not only was Glinda one of the most memorable type in the iconic Judy Garland film , but she also served as a primary influence on Gregory Maguire’sWickedprequel , which expanded upon Glinda ’s backstory and was after adapted into the darling stage musical and pic adaptation . With Ariana Grande nominated for an Academy Award for Best substantiate Actress for her astonishing performance as Glinda inWicked , it ’s important to acknowledge this would not have been potential if her character had not been expand upon for the 1939 movie .
WORST: Peeves the Poltergeist
Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone (2001)
TheHarry Potterseries neglect many matter across its eight films , and although it would have been impossible to fit everything into their limited runtime , one unforgivable skip was Peeves the Poltergeist . While Peeves was a beloved graphic symbol in the novels who was seen causing mischief and running murderously through Hogwarts , his absence seizure , especially in the first movie , Harry Potter and the Sorcerer ’s Stone , was particularly frustrating .
While it ’s understandable there ’s not enough meter to film each and every present moment from the novel , the reasonableness the absence of Peeves really frustrates lecturer is because they actually filmed picture with his character . peeve was played by the British comic Rik Mayall , yet all of his scenes were cut from the final version of the film . Luckily , the upcoming HBO TV series has the opportunity to right retiring wrongs , andit ’s hop that Peeves will at last come out in aHarry Potteradaptation .
BEST: Alice Was Less Passive
Alice in Wonderland (2010)
While Lewis Carroll’sAlice in Wonderlandwas one of the most imaginative and influential illusion Book ever written , there ’s no denying that the presentation of Alice was incredibly inactive . As a story that ’s out of whole step with modern expectation for a strong , invest distaff lead , Alice in Wonderlandsuffered from the passiveness of its chief character , whom thing appeared to just happen to , rather than her taking activity . This was literary criticism that was effectively addressed in Tim Burton ’s interpretation , which focused on an older Alice who was no longer a passive bystander .
Instead of just cast aimlessly , Burton ’s version ofAlice in Wonderlandsaw its protagonist go on a pursuit as she ’s tasked with defeating the Red Queen and restoring order to this fantasy human race . While Alice still find iconic quality like the White Rabbit and the Cheshire Cat , she does so as a character with her own agency who ’s in charge of her destiny . This was a subtle change that transform the dynamic of the total cinema and made Alice a far more compelling booster .
WORST: The Absence of Bella’s Inner Monologue
Twilight (2008)
Stephenie Meyer’sTwilightbook series was a cultural phenomenon that sawyoung readers all over the Earth link with the dear story of Bella Swan and Edward Cullen . While the film adaptation was a major achiever commercially , it also have poor vital response and was the case of far-flung mocking and ridicule online . One reason the shock of the novel did n’t translate as well to the screen was the absence seizure of Bell ’s internal monologue , which allowed reviewer to connect with her on an emotional level .
Without really gaining insight into Bella ’s inner persuasion physical process , her decisions appear nonsensical . Viewers who had not say the books were then left scratching their heads about some of her actions . Bella ’s monologue was what grounded theTwilightnovel as readers experienced the conflicted excited intensity of her kinship with Jacob and Edward , while in the moving-picture show , it just experience like matter happened without explanation and that Bella acted recklessly .
BEST: Aragorn’s Reluctance To Take The Throne
The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King (2003)
One cardinal role scene that was present in Peter Jackson’sThe Lord of the Ringsfilms but wanting from J.R.R. Tolkien ’s original novel was Aragorn ’s reluctance to take the throne . In the record book , Aragorn ’s journey toward the throne was far more straightforward , and he accepted his use as the rightful heritor to the toilet of Gondor . However , in the moving picture , Aragon ’s difficulty in accepting his lot was a key composition that made him a far more human and relatable character .
Adding this good sense of struggle showcased the complexities of being a leader and that a true hero must worm with self - uncertainty and the exercising weight of responsibility . As a man torn between tariff and doubt , Aragon ’s eventual embrace of his destiny made the conclusion ofThe Return of the Kingeven more emotionally impactful . As a watershed moment in the history of phantasy movie theater , Aragorn ’s journey inThe Return of the Kingwas one of many aspect that contribute to this Best Picture - winning triumph ’s dumfounding legacy .
WORST: Azog the Defiler
The Hobbit (2012 - 2014)
While Peter Jackson revolutionize fantasy cinema with his astounding adaptations of J.R.R. Tolkien’sThe Lord of the Ringsseries , the same can not be say aboutThe Hobbit . As the darling but abbreviated story of Bilbo Baggins ’s quest to reclaim the dwarves ’ home and treasure from the dragon Smaug , this was not a fib that necessitate three separate picture . The expanded story of Jackson’sThe Hobbitseries mean that many raw aspects were needlessly added , such as the orc foeman Azog the Defiler .
Summary
The Hobbit movie series is a phantasy adventure trilogy direct by Peter Jackson , based on J.R.R. Tolkien ’s novel The Hobbit . Set 60 years before The Lord of the Rings , the cinema follow Bilbo Baggins ' quest to domesticize the Lonely Mountain from the firedrake Smaug . The series grossed nearly $ 3 billion worldwide and is know for its elaborate visuals and epical storytelling .
While Azog was mention in brief in Tolkien ’s original novel , The Hobbitfilms needlessly expanded his character reference to pad the runtime and put up a cardinal resister . In the Book , Azog was already long dead before Bilbo ’s story begin , and his addition served no major purpose and just finger entirely unnecessary . Azog was just one of many things thatThe Hobbitmovies get wrong , and he only served to distract from the lightsome adventure that made the originalfantasybook so compelling in the first station .
Custom Image By Yailin Chacon
