Related
Warning : The followers comprise SPOILERS forBatman : The Long Halloween , Part 2and the graphic novelBatman : The Long Halloween .
Content Warning : This clause hold description of fierceness against womanhood in a fictional film setting .
The cease ofBatman : The Long Halloween , Part 2varies wildly from the twist ending of the original pictorial novel . While the ultimate identity of the true killers at the heart of the story remains for the most part the same , the motivations are completely unlike . Additionally , the plastic film does a in force line of work of allowing the audience to see out the mystery on their own .
in the beginning published as a 13 - part mini - series in 1996,Batman : The Long Halloweenis widely reckon as one of the best Batman write up ever enjoin . put immediately after the events ofBatman : Year One , the story detail how GCPD Captain James Gordon , District Attorney Harvey Dent and Batman entered into an alliance to bring down the empire of Carmine " The Roman " Falcone , the leader of the organized crime families that were the rightful power in Gotham City . Their plan were complicated by the issue of a new serial Orcinus orca dub Holiday , who targeted members of the Gotham mob on major holidays , starting with the slaying of Carmine Falcone ’s nephew , Johnny Viti , on Halloween Night .
bear on : Batman : The Long Halloween Cast Guide - Every Confirmed Character
The mystery story ofthe Holiday killingsdrove the plot ofBatman : The Long Halloween , even as Harvey Dent sunk deeply into depression over his unfitness to build a case against Carmine Falcone . By the remnant of the story , Harvey Dent was metamorphose into the villain Two - Face and abandon blind justice for blind opportunity , lead a mob of supervillains he freed from Arkham Asylum to bump off Carmine Falcone in his habitation . These effect still play out inBatman : The Long Halloween , Part Two , but the cinema ’s resolution is quite different from the book .
The Long Halloween’s Holiday Identity Twist
Two - Face deliver himself toJim Gordonand Batman on the rooftop of GCPD headquarters , profess not only to the murder of Carmine Falcone but all of the Holiday killings . This on the face of it confirmed a theory that Batman had develop that Harvey Dent was Holiday , after searching the cellar of his home and finding a pair of modify .22 pistols - the precise case of gun for hire used to comport out the Holiday killing . This seemingly empty the case and Two - Face was committed to Arkham Asylum , but there was one matter that troubled Batman about his former friend ’s confession .
This conduct Batman to approach Harvey Dent ’s married woman Gilda , whom he receive in the basement of their home burning the lid , coat and gun of Holiday in the furnace , along with a collecting of photo . Gilda dispassionately told Batman about how , years earlier when she was in college , she had fallen in sexual love with Carmine Falcone ’s eldest son , Alberto , and how the two had eloped when Gilda discovered she was fraught . Their Latinian language did not please The Roman , who would not bide a youngster born out of marriage in his family , or his Logos wed a woman that he had not choose for him . While his code of award would not allow Falcone to stamp out a woman , he did have the wedlock annulled and forced Gilda to get an abortion . This build off a conversation inBatman : The Long Halloween , Part One , where Alberto Falcone talk to Batman about how much he hat his Father of the Church for taking off the only woman he had ever have it off , just before he was murdered by Holiday .
Years later , Gilda incite to Gotham City , where she marriedHarvey Dent , calculate that he had the best luck of anyone in bringing down Carmine Falcone ’s deplorable imperium and that she could press him towards that end . However , as Harvey begin to focalize more on battling his own inside demons , Gilda took thing into her own hand and became Holiday , killing Falcone ’s family and associates off , include her bemused love , Alberto . Gilda asked Batman if he mean to arrest her or tell Jim Gordon that Harvey had lie to protect her . Batman decline to answer , beyond confirming that Harvey did not give her up , at least " not knowingly , " and that he mistrust that Harvey knew who Holiday was after Two - Face acted to cover Holiday ’s escape follow Holiday ’s slaying of crime party boss Sal Maroni .
Related : Batman : The Long Halloween : Every DC Easter Egg & Reference In Part 1
The Oxford Connection Explained
The hint that tipped Batman off as to Harvey Dent not being Holiday was an Oxford University banner hanging in the same cellar workshop where he discover the fit .22 pistols . Jim Gordon confirmed thatHarvey Denthad never attended Oxford , having pursued all of his formal education topically at Gotham University . sleep together that Alberto Falcone had attend Oxford lead Batman to the conclusion that Gilda Dent was the lost love that Alberto Falcone mention and , logically , the real Holiday cause of death .
The Long Halloween’s Original Ending
The penultimate chapter of the originalBatman : The Long Halloweenminiseries stop with Alberto Falcone gunning down Sal Maroni . This was a scandalous ontogeny , as Alberto Falcone was take for granted to be the fourth Holiday victim , having patently been take before accrue overboard at a New Year ’s Eve party held on his beginner ’s racing yacht . Alberto Falcone confessed to all the Holiday killing and was committed to Arkham Asylum , just before his Church Father , Carmine Falcone , was murdered by Two - Face .
When he surrendered himself to Jim Gordon and Batman in the final chapter , Two - Faceasked them if they had figured out that there were two Holiday killer . They presumed that he was referring to the fact that , having killed Carmine Falcone on Halloween Night , one year after the first Holiday murder , that Two - Face himself was also Holiday , in a way . The truth was revealed in the Holy Scripture ’s concluding scene , as Gilda Dent was bear witness burning the hat , coat and heavy weapon of Holiday while talking to herself about how she had entrust the first three Holiday murder only for Harvey to have fill over for her after he figured out what she was doing . She also explained to the audience that she did it all for Harvey , hop that once Falcone was dealt with that they could focus on having a household together without Harvey work the long nights that the Falcone case demanded .
How The Long Halloween Movie Improves The Book’s Mystery
For all the grand fictional character momentsBatman : The Long Halloweenhad and how much it has regulate other Batman adjustment ( particularlyThe Dark Knight ) it has also drawn criticism from some enigma fans for not give the audience a fair chance to solve the Holiday murder display case on their own . The revelation that Alberto Falcone fake his own slaying come out of nowhere and there is nothing to betoken his involution beyond the fact that the last two Holiday victims before Sal Maroni were a random coroner and Carmine Falcone ’s sis , Carla Viti , who was remove while digging through the records in the Gotham City Coroner ’s Office . Alberto also had no apparent motive for the Holiday killings asunder from require to rise to his sire that he was capable of help oneself out in the kin business . The idea that Gilda Dent entrust the first three murders is as random , especially when she was depict as being hospitalise throughout November and December following the bombing of her and Harvey ’s house on Halloween Night .
Related : Batman : The Long Halloween Part 2 - Biggest Comics Changes
The film rendering ofBatman : The Long Halloweeneliminated this plot of land hole , defecate itHarvey Dentwho was hospitalized following the bombing of the Dent menage rather than Gilda . It definitively carry off Alberto Falcone as a defendant at the destruction ofBatman : The Long Halloween , Part 1 , by having Holiday off him in front of Batman and Catwoman . The Oxford banner clue gave the audience a chance of colligate Gilda to the lost love that Alberto cite and the movie also gave Gilda a stronger motivation for execution than just wanting her workaholic husband to drop by the wayside chasing after a mob hirer and focus on their spirit together . to boot , the motion-picture show ’s conclusion does a good job of verify Batman ’s abilities as a police detective and gives Gilda someone to confess to besides the hearing , with it being leave completely opened as to whether or not Batman will see Gilda punish for her crimes or abide by the last noble forfeiture Harvey Dent made before Two - Face took over .
Batman: The Long Halloween Post-Credits Scene Setup
Batman : The Long Halloween , Part 2has a post - credits shot , which seems to have been admit to set up the next DC Comics animated photographic film . The brief scene sees Alfred answering the door of Wayne Manor , a stadium of candy at the quick , expecting trick - or - negotiant . Instead of dress up nipper , he come up costumed men , specifically The Flash and Green Arrow . The abbreviated scenery end with Alfred call up for his employer , say " It ’s for you , sir . " There was nothing elsewhere in the movie to indicate that this version of Batman was already part of the Justice League or a similar chemical group , so this could be setting the stage for a new animatedJustice Leaguemovie about the squad ’s earliest days . It may also be setting up the alive adjustment ofInjustice , another classical graphic novel series in which Green Arrow and The Flash played major roles .
More : Jensen Ackles ' Long Halloween Is Doing Robert Pattinson ’s Batman Story First
