Related
Warning : The followers incorporate SPOILERS forBatman : The Long Halloween , Part 2and the vivid novelBatman : The Long Halloween .
Content Warning : This clause incorporate descriptions of violence against women in a fancied picture show mise en scene .
Batman : The Long Halloween , Part 2fixes a major plot hole from the original graphical novel regarding the identity of the sequent sea wolf Holiday . Batman : The Long Halloweenis considered one of the greatestBatmanstories of all time and has inspire plot elements that were later inaugurate into theGothamtelevision series andThe Dark Knight . Despite this , some readers have complain its final plot twist cause little horse sense ; a problem the recent animated film version have tried to correct .
The central whodunit ofThe Long Halloweeninvolveda serial killer dub Holiday , who targeted members of the Falcone crime family unit on major holidays . There were two major twists in the final chapter , with the first being that Alberto Falcone , the firstborn boy of Gotham City ’s godfather Carmine Falcone , had forge his death and gone on to murder his father ’s main rival , Sal Maroni . Alberto profess to all of the Holiday slaying , but the final moments of the Holy Scripture give away the second wind ; that the first three Holiday murders had been committed by Gilda Dent , the married woman of District Attorney Harvey Dent , and he had continued her killing fling before becoming Two - fount .
Related : Jensen Ackles ' tenacious Halloween Is Doing Robert Pattinson ’s Batman Story First
Many mystery fan have criticizedDC’sBatman : The Long Halloweenfor not give the reader a chance to solve the murders on their own , as the twinned revelations Alberto Falcone was still alive and Gilda Dent was a killer were not foreshadowed at all . The estimation Gilda could have committed the first three murders seemed especially impossible , give that she was hospitalized and obviously bed - ridden for most of November and December following the bombardment of the Dent home by Carmine ’s men on Halloween Night . It seemed unbelievable , despite her title to the contrary , that Gilda could have snuck out of her infirmary room on Thanksgiving even while her married man was at peace , shoot several mobsters to destruction and return undetected while still involve discourse that stay fresh her in the hospital an additional calendar month . The Long Halloweenfilm adaptation set up this , by birth Harvey be the one who was hospitalized , so it made sense when she was expose as Holiday .
Long Halloween , Part 2made another change that improved Gilda ’s motivations . In the comedian , Gilda had no reason for starting her kill spree beyond hope her married man might focalize on set about a family if he no longer had to puzzle out nights building a type against Carmine Falcone . The film introduces a newfangled subplot , in which Gilda was let out as the college ravisher of Carmine ’s Logos , Alberto , whom she get hitched with in secret while attending Oxford . Falcone did not approve of and had their wedlock annulled after force a pregnant Gilda to have an miscarriage . This head Gilda to marry Harvey , who she find was the man most capable of bringing down the Falcone empire .
Fans of the original graphic novel may not consort that the changes made byBatman : The Long Halloween , Part 2improved upon the storey , even if the raw version impart the audience a good chance of execute the mystery on their own . Some might argue the change in Gilda ’s motivation , while making her more proactive as a villain , only shifts the reason for her murder from one sexist cliché to another . In any eccentric , the motion-picture show does address the major plot of ground hole pose by a bed - depend on woman somehow killing a group of temper mobsters while they ’re in the centre of Thanksgiving dinner .
More : How Batman : The Long Halloween Part 2 Post - Credits Scene Sets Up Injustice
