Related
Despite both being heroes and founding members of the Avengers , HulkandThorhave made a wont of collide at every possible opportunity . However , 2024 lend a dark new chapter to their chronicle of mix it up , asThor reveal he can vote down the Green Goliath whenever he require . While Thor may not bequiteas physically knock-down as the Strongest One There Is , he does have a failsafe move if the Hulkneedsto be lay off .
The reveal came in 2024’sAvengers : Twilight , from Chip Zdarsky , Daniel Acuña , Cory Petit and Joe Caramagna . In the narrative , theHulk is pervert by the Red Skull , who utilise Ultron ’s technology to release him into a killing political machine . After assail multiple countries with Vasco da Gamma warfare , the Red Skull tries to use Hulk to bring down the Avengers , resulting in his concluding face - off with the God of Thunder .
After innocents are massacre and Bruce Banner solicit Thor to halt him , the Odinson finally unleashes his contingency plan . Punching Hulk into the ocean , Thor places Mjolnir on his chest . Because of the ' worthy ' enchantment , Hulk ca n’t hook the legendary weapon , and quickly drowns under the water .
Hulk claims to be " the substantial One There Is , " but a rival Marvel character proved they ’re stronger by turn over him his most definitive red .
Thor Kills Hulk by Drowning Him with Mjolnir
Thor Reveals What It Would Take for Him to Use This Lethal Tactic
Avengers : Twilightis localize in a potential future tense where the populace have recede faith in the Avengers . The team dissolve , allowing Red Skull to intimate himself into the US government , usingTony Stark ’s son Jamesto penetrate the most in advance levels of technology . An aging Captain America decides to return for one last time , pucker a team of Avengers which includes Thor , an old Ms. Marvel , and new Cuban sandwich Hawkeye , as well as finally winning James to his side . Sadly , Hulk is just too far gone to save or ransom , with Ultron and then Red Skull having had year to fall in him to their will .
Hulk ’s demand for O is how Batman pulsate him during their epical Marvel / DC crossover fight .
gratefully , the serial did offer fans a consoling epilogue , asBruce Banner ( and Tony Stark , who also did n’t survive the adventure ) wakes up in Asgard , having been give a seat in the hereafter by Thor . It ’s the God of Thunder ’s excuse for how their conflict end , finally giving Bruce some peace and happiness after years of becoming the exact life weapon he ’d always venerate .
While this escapade did n’t take shoes in Marvel ’s mainstream timeline , it did unwrap that Thor has been holding this move in military reserve for years , planning for the sidereal day when he might be called on to finish the Hulk for good . The older , aweary Thor has basically retired from Earth following the Avengers disbanding , taking his true place as ruler of Asgard . That spend a penny it even more tragic that he ’d be called back only to cease up kill his former friend . However , as smart as this tactic for kill Hulk is , would it actually work ?
Hulk ’s decease inAvengers : Twilightbegs one interrogation - ca n’t he breathe underwater ?
I just realized that despite his incredible power , Hulk has been operate at his lower limit military capability his entire career - but he can easily get impregnable .
Would Drowning the Hulk Actually Work?
Marvel Lore Confirms the Answer Is… Complicated
Hulk ’s vulnerability to drowning is a complicated question , chiefly because Marvel lore has n’t been particularly consistent . It ’s canyon that Hulk needs oxygen , but hecanhold his breathing place for days at a meter . However , on occasions where the air has been force from his lungs , he ’s quickly become vulnerable - for example in Roy Thomas and George Perez’sFantastic Four # 166 , wherethe team beat the Hulkby glow up the oxygen in his lungs , then cutting off his further air supply with a force field . Reed Richards sample to replicate this victory inContest of Champions II , only for Hulk to turn the tables by literally inhaling him .
astonishingly , this is how Batman vanquish Hulkwhen they fought in Len Wein and José Luis García - López’sDC Special Series # 27 . Knowing he could n’t beat the Hulk in a strong-arm fighting , Batman used knockout gas to take down the Jade Giant , kicking him as hard as potential in the stomach so as to wind up the Hulk and force him to take a breath in . It ’s apparent that while the Hulk can hold his breath basically indefinitely , once he ’s out of oxygen , he needs it as urgently and instantly as any man . This stand the event ofAvengers : Twilight , as Hulk is tackled hollo into the water system , with no chance to hold his breath .
However , on rarified occasions Hulkhasspecifically demonstrate an ability to catch one’s breath underwater . This famously happened in Peter David and Lee Weeks’The Incredible Hulk # 77 . In that issue , Hulk begin to drownbuthis ' adaptive phylogeny ' causes him to grow an entirely Modern organ - one which produces an emulsion that allow him to breathe underwater . The estimate has n’t been used much outside this story , but it ’s still canon , and it makes horse sense believe the wild shapeshifting Hulk has achieved on other occasions .
Hulk has one jaw - dropping way to fly the coop Thor ’s attack , and it ’s something he ’s done before - shoot Mjolnir through his body .
The Hulk has experienced no shortage of dread transformations in his more recent Marvel Comics stories , but his latest one might be the worst yet .
Thor’s Attack Works, But It Can’t Be Used Consistently
Hulk Just Has Too Many Ways to Escape If He Wants To
The definitive answer is offer by Al Ewing and Joe Bennett’sImmortal Hulk , which reveal themystical panorama of Vasco da Gamma radiation . That story confirm that Hulk ’s powers are partly magic , and that da Gamma radiation turns humans into ' metaphor people , ' whose magnate are an extension of their identity and psychological DoS . Since BannerwantsThor to vote down him inTwilight , it make smell out his supererogatory organ would n’t come into play . This also explains why Hulk did n’t practice his most grisly agency of escaping Mjolnir .
In the recentHulk # 7by Donny Cates and Martin Coccolo , Thor employ this same Mjolnir trick to pin Hulk to the ground . Unwilling to be trapped , Hulk pushes against the ground so hard thatMjolnir buck a hole through his body- a severe wound , but one he ’s capable of come through and healing . It ’s a beyond extreme way of life to lam Thor ’s hammer , but one that ’s ultimately efficacious . It ’s deserving notice that , at this point , Bruce Banner was in dominance of the Hulk ’s body , and this proficiency might not even occur to the actual Green Goliath .
Ultimately , retaliator : Twilightdepicts a Hulk who has been out of ascendency for eld and require nothing more than for Thor to discharge him from Red Skull ’s control . It ’s likely because Bruce Bannerwantsto die out that Hulk does n’t hold his breather , spring up his emulsion organ , or tear Mjolnir through his consistence .
Custom Image by Robert Wood (From Alex Ross)
Hulk ’s brutish rage means that it ’s possible these technique for survival simply would n’t hap to him , and even with the organ , he wouldeventuallydie if trap underwater . Nevertheless , whileThor ’s contingence plan to kill Hulk with Mjolnir is a sassy manoeuvre no - one else could use , it ’s definitely not one he can rely on to easily beatHulkin the future .
avenger : Twilightis usable now from Marvel Comics .
Associated with the mythical realm of Asgard , Thor is a Marvel Comics hero who channels the baron of thunder to slay their foes . Though the name is chiefly tie to Thor Odinson , several other graphic symbol also take on the role of God of Thunder , including Odinson ’s erotic love interest , Jane Foster . Odin is portray as a physically imposing hero with incredible strength and typically wield the dwarven forged hammer , Mjolnir .
The Hulk , a Marvel Comics superhero create by Stan Lee and Jack Kirby , is physicist Bruce Banner transform by gamma irradiation . He morphs into a giant , green - skinned creature of immense strength and invulnerability when see red . fight with his shift , Hulk allies with other champion , battling villains while balancing his intellectual with irrepressible madness , making him a central figure in Marvel ’s macrocosm .
Associated with the mythical realm of Asgard, Thor is a Marvel Comics hero who channels the power of thunder to slay their foes. Though the name is chiefly tied to Thor Odinson, several other characters also take on the role of God of Thunder, including Odinson’s love interest, Jane Foster. Odin is portrayed as a physically imposing hero with incredible strength and typically wields the dwarven forged hammer, Mjolnir.
