Related
A compelling lover theory aim a more electropositive destiny forWatchmen’sHooded Justicethan what was antecedently assumed . While both the 2012Before security guard : Minutemenprequel comics by Darwyn Cooke and the 2019WatchmenTV show each provide their own potential version of what encounter to Hooded Justice , the original graphic novel leaves his fortune unresolved to interpretation . Due to this ambiguity , fans have been conjecture about what incisively happened to him since the comic was originally unloosen .
Watchmen , a comic write by Alan Moore with nontextual matter by David Gibbons , is one of the most influential graphic novels of all time . The account follows a group of superheroes in an alternate translation of the Cold War . While rivet in the main on thenewer heroes like Rorschach , the comedian also flesh out the elder generation of superheroes through flashbacks and supplemental document like excerpts from book and newspapers . One of the oldest Hero to appear in this human beings is Hooded Justice , a brutal vigilante who was shrouded in enigma . When the superheroes were pressure to take the stand in front of the House Un - American Activities Commission in the 1950s , Hooded Justice refused and subsequently go away . The most usual theory for what pass off to him is that he was murdered by the psychotic Comedian for interrupting his assault of fellow grinder Silk Spectre . However , one theory is a bit more optimistic .
Related : Watchmen ’s Most Mocked Detail Is An Astounding Real - Life Phenomenon
In a 1999 paper titledOcculted security guard : The dead on target Fate of " Hooded Justice " and " Captain Metropolis"by James Gifford , the author pose a theory thatHooded Justice is actually alive and well , survive with his partner Captain Metropolis . This theory is based on a panel in the very first chapter of the book , feature a military man who looks a destiny like Hooded Justice ’s say civilian identity , and another homo who greatly resembles Captain Metropolis . In addition to their strong-arm appearances , the two wear bowties that look like domino mask , implying that they may be link up to superheroes in some way and are foregrounded in the panel , elevating their significance to the reader . Gifford posits that based on this combination of details , the two are meant to be Hooded Justice and Captain Metropolis , who forge their deaths to live a quiet life sentence together , away from jimmy oculus . The theory is a much more pleasant one to consider than the alternative .
Unfortunately , the theory has been pretty disproven . According toCBR , Dave Gibbons , the creative person ofWatchmen , has read regarding the possibility , " That was n’t our intention , but it ’s such an interesting and plausible theory that I ’m loth to deny it ! " However , while this may show that the advise fates of these characters were n’t in the first place part of Moore and Gibbons ’ artistic vision , Gibbons is not outright abnegate the theory . And once a piece of art is released into the world it could be argued that artistic intention is a lot less important than how reader rede it . This definitely seems like an line of reasoning Moore would support at least , given his own belief in vision being able to shape realism .
Regardless of the veracity of the hypothesis , or what the original author might think of it , the possibility is a very satisfying one . Given how bleak the world andending ofWatchmenis , it is courteous to imagine at least two character engender a glad conclusion . This contrast with the destiny of the other characters inWatchmenis what makes this fan theory aboutHooded Justiceso heavy .
More : Steve Ditko ’s Greatest Achievement Is n’t Spider - Man , It ’s Watchmen
Sources : Occulted Watchmen , CBR
